When Talk Therapy Has Not Helped Your Anxiety: What to Consider Next
If you have spent time in therapy and still feel anxious, it can be discouraging. Understanding your patterns is useful, but you may also need opportunities to practise different responses in everyday life. A lack of progress is a reason to review your care, not evidence that you have failed or that all talking therapies are ineffective.
Talk therapy includes more than reflection
Talking therapies vary. Cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT), for example, can include practical exercises and carefully planned exposure to feared situations, as well as work on thoughts and beliefs. Other approaches have different aims and methods. It is not accurate to describe them all as surface-level conversation or to claim that hypnotherapy is faster or more effective for everyone.
When sessions feel repetitive
If you feel stuck, tell your therapist. Ask what you are working towards, how progress will be reviewed and what you can practise between appointments. It may help to adjust the plan, review the fit between you and the therapist, or seek another professional opinion.
Understanding automatic responses
Anxiety can involve thoughts, physical sensations, avoidance and responses that feel automatic. These patterns are influenced by many factors, including biology, experiences and current pressures. Describing them as an internal program can be a metaphor, but it does not establish that anxiety lives in one hidden part of the mind or that a fixed percentage of behaviour is controlled there.
Practice rather than promises
Learning to respond differently can take practice. We may explore how you react to uncertainty, how you respond to anxious predictions and which small steps are manageable. Change is individual, and neither effortless change nor a fixed number of sessions can be promised.
Where Clinical Hypnotherapy may fit
I use Strategic Psychotherapy and, where appropriate, Clinical Hypnotherapy. Hypnotherapy involves focused attention and therapeutic suggestions that may help you rehearse more useful responses. Some people find it helpful, but results vary and the evidence differs across techniques and conditions. It should not be presented as a proven replacement for established anxiety treatments.
Working collaboratively
We discuss your goals, circumstances and preferences before deciding how to proceed. You can ask questions, raise concerns or stop an exercise. Your history matters, and practical work in the present does not mean dismissing past experiences.
What to do if your current treatment is not helping
- Discuss your concerns and goals with your current clinician.
- Ask whether the approach is appropriate for your symptoms and what alternatives are available.
- Consider a GP or mental health assessment if symptoms persist, worsen or interfere with daily life.
- If you take prescribed medication, speak with your prescriber before making any changes.
Questions about talking therapies
What is talk therapy?
It is a broad term for psychological treatments that use conversation and, often, structured exercises to work on difficulties. Depending on the approach, treatment may address thoughts, emotions, relationships, behaviour and physical responses.
What kinds are available?
Examples include CBT, psychodynamic, humanistic and interpersonal therapies. They are not interchangeable, and the most appropriate option depends on the difficulty being treated, the evidence for that approach and your preferences.
Does not improving with CBT mean I need hypnotherapy?
Not necessarily. It is worth reviewing the treatment plan, its delivery and any other factors affecting progress with a qualified clinician. Hypnotherapy may be discussed as one option, but no single approach suits everyone.
About the Author
Jonathan “Jono” Smith is a Strategic Psychotherapist and Clinical Hypnotherapist at New Day Strategic Therapy. He trained at the Institute of Applied Psychology and formerly served as president of the International Strategic Psychotherapists Association.
For an overview of my approach, session options and the complimentary 20-minute conversation, visit anxiety therapy on the Central Coast. You can also enquire about an appointment, with no obligation to proceed.
You can explore more of Jono’s work on The Mindset Channel.
